CORPORATION: An ingenious device for obtaining individual profit without individual responsibility (Ambrose Bierce. The Devils Dictionary, 1911)
In many countries (especially developed ones), parents are responsible for the actions that their kids commit e.g. in New York (USA), if kids are found skipping class, parents may even end up paying huge fines. But why are parents responsible for what another human being is or does? Why should they be blamed for committed actions that aren’t theirs? Even though they are their children, to what degree is a parent responsible? Is "being a child" a sufficient excuse to blame his/her parent?
Stepping aside from the previous statement, we can concentrate on Corporations. If we compare what a corporation IS to the previous statement, I think we could say that it relates: if parents can be held responsible for their children’s actions, shouldn’t corporations "parents" respond for their "children’s" actions? IS IT correct to address companies as "children"? If a corporation is considered as a person (juridical person, but still a person), it must have parents from which it came from, or is it a mistake to think such a thing? In this blog, I would like to try to analyze the following question:
Should individuals (directors, employees, shareholders) bear any responsibility for the actions of a corporation? If so, to what degree?
![]() |
1 |
Im Juan Pablo and Im a CEO for XXX corp. Should I focus on what is right or should I just keep making Money?
ALL corporations state to have different goals (according to their economical activity, the sector they move around in, the country they belong to, and so on), but at the end, they all converge with the same goal: to make the shareholders richer. How? By doing what they do best, finally translating to "reducing costs". I think we are all fed up from hearing this over and over again. But what we don’t here so often is who’s to blame when in this process something goes wrong, when a felony is committed, when a crime is made. If we were to answer this question, we could see it from the legal aspect and the ethical aspect:
If we were to blame legally a corporation, the person responsible for its actions would be the CEO, the manager or the representative. Why? Because that person swore to pay for what its company did.
If we were to see it from an ethical point of view, I think that ALL the people involved inside the company, would have to pay for its actions. Some might think that it isn’t fare, but of course it isn’t; how can we compare the responsibility of a CEO to that of a janitor from the same tobacco company? Who is guiltier? In my personal opinion, the CEO.
Let’s make things even clearer:
If I own a motorcycle, I know that I’m responsible to keep it clean, keep it tuned, and keep it nice and pretty. Let’s say that someday, that bike gets stolen and a felony is committed by another person but riding my bike. Do you think that I won’t be blamed for anything at all? Because of a mistake, should I pass unpunished? I think that it’s the same thing for corporations: if a group of people own a company (they together have all the shares of that company), shouldn’t they be always aware of what the company does? Shouldn’t they pay for the actions committed by their own assets? But let’s say that a problem started because of one employee. Who should pay? I think that both, but the owners have more responsibility.
![]() |
2 |
I think that we are not far away from this reality...
As a final conclusion, I think that the way corporations, technology and societies grow, there’s not a chance for ethics and morality to keep up; it is not easy to judge something that isn’t fully regulated. These aspects have to be considered quickly, because corporations can go unpunished just because there isn’t a specific law for it. And if not, why should a person who kills another person is incarcerated if a CEO passes unpunished for killing slowly and painfully the entire planet? Isn’t it the same when a person steals a thousand pesos to when he steals a bank? Why blame at all?
THINK ABOUT IT!!!
Bibliography
Soulpancake. Accessed on 21/02/2011. http://www.soulpancake.com/question/51793/who-is-morally-responsible-for-the-actions-of-corporations-seeing-as-theyre-granted-the-rights-of-individuals.html
Pictures
Videos